For a Sustainable Future, Measure Economic Impact Not Output - Title Image

For a Sustainable Future, Measure Economic Impact Not Output

Economic statistics do not measure social or environmental impact.

January 17, 2020   |    By Scott Minerd, Global CIO

A version of this article appeared in Barron's.

As a longtime consumer of economic statistics—some would say a fanatical, obsessive consumer of such stats—I have come to realize two important things about data. First, you have to look at the right numbers. And second, even the “right” numbers miss a lot when it comes to predicting future outcomes.

I’ve seen this time and again, especially at a few major economic turning points:

Having grown up in Western Pennsylvania during the 1960s, I lived in a world where 40 percent of the nation’s coal came from within 100 miles of Pittsburgh, which made it an economic powerhouse. But all the data describing the region’s growth in those halcyon days failed to anticipate the economic costs of the erosion of the steel industry and the environmental damage that would be paid over many generations.

From 1961 through 1966, average annual U.S Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew about 5 percent, while the unemployment rate averaged 4.8 percent, and inflation was under 2 percent. Knowing just these data points, you would never get a sense of the economic and social inequities that led to 1967’s Long Hot Summer of race riots.

In 2006 and 2007 most investors and policymakers missed the signs that the engine of economic growth associated with rapid house price appreciation would prove to be the source of global financial disaster.

Today, globalization, which has brought economic prosperity to more people around the world than ever before, has also been accompanied by greater wealth and income inequality, weaker social safety nets, and rising carbon emissions with consequences that will be felt for years to come.

Many treat GDP as an all-encompassing measure of national wellbeing, but it does not measure other costs of that output nor any progress made in meeting social or environmental challenges, many of which have yet to be realized. For example, if global GDP growth of 5 percent is accompanied by the Earth’s surface temperatures rising 0.5 degrees Celsius, but surface temperatures fall when global GDP grows 3 percent, how should we compare those two growth outcomes?

GDP does not even do a great job at measuring economic output. Difficulties in measuring an increasingly digital and services-oriented economy, flawed methodologies, and significant procyclical revisions all make GDP a faulty gauge of economic security. Nor are other conventional macroeconomic indicators fully up to the task: I would be hard-pressed to say that the current 50-year low in the U.S. unemployment rate accurately conveys the wellbeing of most people.

The irony here is that data measuring progress in environmental and social challenges already exist to some extent; but business, economic, investment, and public policy communities aren’t paying the appropriate attention.

If there is any hope of reaching the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by 2030, it is imperative that we use existing and new data sets to measure environmental and social progress in economic terms. There are several ways that this could be accomplished.

Peter Drucker once said that “What gets measured gets managed.” With better real-time data, we will not only be able to track environmental and social progress, but we can also be held more accountable for the results. Policymakers, who deploy conventional fiscal and monetary tools to offset rising unemployment or slowing economic growth, could develop new, data-centric, evidence-based policy to introduce potentially disruptive yet necessary measures. Policies and incentives such as a carbon tax, land use reform, and programs to raise labor force participation through the tax code could all be made more effective with the right data to measure progress.

The good news is that we no longer need to trade off economic growth for environmentally and socially sound activity or give up strong and stable returns in order to make responsible investments. In fact, in the future, I believe it will be impossible to deliver economic prosperity without a principled approach to sustainability. With the right measurement tools and advances in technology, meeting the SDGs can lift the standard of living for all at a faster pace than by clinging to older, outdated paradigms.

The biggest challenge in meeting the SDGs, however, is to induce investors and policymakers to lengthen their time horizons. While the consequences of inaction on social and environmental challenges are increasingly evident, with little immediate incentive to take action today, we ensure that the collective costs will be far greater in the future. This “tragedy of the horizon” is that once the failure to meet the SDGs becomes a defining issue, it may be too late. Until the public and private sectors are incentivized to do what is in their own economic best interests, the Sustainable Development Goals will remain elusive. By rethinking how we use data to measure progress and developing the right free-market incentives, our chances for success will be much better.

Important Notices and Disclosures

This material is distributed or presented for informational or educational purposes only and should not be considered a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product, or as investing advice of any kind. This material is not provided in a fiduciary capacity, may not be relied upon for or in connection with the making of investment decisions, and does not constitute a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell securities. The content contained herein is not intended to be and should not be construed as legal or tax advice and/or a legal opinion. Always consult a financial, tax and/or legal professional regarding your specific situation.

This material contains opinions of the author, but not necessarily those of Guggenheim Partners, LLC or its subsidiaries. The opinions contained herein are subject to change without notice. Forward looking statements, estimates, and certain information contained herein are based upon proprietary and non-proprietary research and other sources. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but are not assured as to accuracy. Past performance is not indicative of future results. There is neither representation nor warranty as to the current accuracy of, nor liability for, decisions based on such information. No part of this material may be reproduced or referred to in any form, without express written permission of Guggenheim Partners, LLC.

Guggenheim Investments represents the following affiliated investment management businesses of Guggenheim Partners, LLC: Guggenheim Partners Investment Management, LLC, Security Investors, LLC, Guggenheim Funds Investment Advisors, LLC, Guggenheim Funds Distributors, LLC, GS GAMMA Advisors, LLC, Guggenheim Partners Europe Limited and Guggenheim Partners India Management.

© 2020 Guggenheim Partners, LLC. All rights reserved. Guggenheim, Guggenheim Partners and Innovative Solutions. Enduring Values. are registered trademarks of Guggenheim Capital, LLC.


Are High-Yield Markets Misjudging Evergrande Risk? - Featured Perspectives
November 24, 2021

Are High-Yield Markets Misjudging Evergrande Risk?

High-yield investors should be weighing the risks of contagion more carefully.

Yield Curve Flattening Carries a Warning About Looming Rate Hike Cycle - Featured Perspectives
November 01, 2021

Yield Curve Flattening Carries a Warning About Looming Rate Hike Cycle

The long end of the yield curve has inverted for the first time since 2009.

Things Couldn’t Be Better - Featured Perspectives
July 30, 2021

Things Couldn’t Be Better

The COVID Delta Variant’s Looming Threat to Risk Assets.


Fixed-Income Outlook 

Midyear 2021 Outlook

Brian Smedley, Chief Economist and Head of Macroeconomic and Investment Research, and Portfolio Manager Adam Bloch provide our macro and markets outlook.

The Long Road to Recovery 

The Long Road to Recovery

Scott Minerd, Chairman of Investments and Global CIO, discussed his outlook for markets and the economy with CNBC’s Brian Sullivan during the Milken Institute 2020 Global Conference.